About Radar Echoes
How big a target looks to a radar is its radar cross-section, σ (sigma): the area of a perfect mirror ball that would send back the same echo. It is measured in square metres, or in dBsm, decibels above one square metre (10 dBsm is 10 m², 20 dBsm is 100 m², −20 dBsm is 0.01 m²). It is rarely the target's real size: a flat plate face-on can look thousands of times bigger than it is, and a stealth shape much smaller.
Pick a target, its size and the band (NATO letters A to M, each set to a typical radar frequency in it, or type any frequency from 0.1 to 100 GHz). The target sits on a turntable in a test chamber; drag the chamber picture, the polar chart or the Aspect slider to turn it (← and → turn it 1°, with Shift 10°). MEASURE turns it once round while the pen draws the pattern, as a real measuring range does. KEEP TRACE leaves the current pattern on the paper in grey so you can compare another (the upright box against the stealth shape, say). 0° is head-on: looking at the front, into the corner, or at a plate's face.
COMPARE puts the target against rounded typical values and works out detection range by the fourth-root rule. FREQUENCY shows how the echo at this angle changes across the bands. To keep it quick, each point on that curve averages the echo at 11 angles spread across the smoothing window: a fair estimate, but for a big ship it can be a couple of decibels off a much finer average.
The vessels sit on the sea unless you turn SEA off. The small boat can be steel or glass fibre (GRP HULL); a glass-fibre boat can show its ENGINE through the hull and carry a REFLECTOR. The 1960s destroyer was designed with no thought for radar; the modern frigate and modern destroyer are shaped to keep their echo down; the carrier is big whatever its shape. The two modern ships carry RAM/RASH, absorbent paint and screens on the parts shaping can't fix; turn it off to see them all metal. SMOOTHING averages a vessel's pattern in power over 1° (the default) or 5° of aspect: a ship at sea yaws and rolls, so a radar never sees the needle-thin flashes of one held perfectly still, and measured ship patterns are published averaged like this. RAW shows the still ship; with smoothing on, the raw pattern is drawn faintly behind the average. All four ships are generic, built from public sizes, not copies of real classes: real warship echoes are secret.
THE STORY
Radar sends out a pulse and listens for the echo. The radar range equation says the echo power falls as the fourth power of range (spreading out on the way there, and again on the way back), so it grows with σ while range only grows as σ¼: sixteen times the echo just doubles the distance a target can be seen, and a target 30 dB smaller is seen at under a fifth of the range.
The exact echo of a sphere comes from Gustav Mie's series of 1908 (Ludvig Lorenz had worked out much the same in 1890). It shows the three regions every target passes through: much smaller than the wavelength, the echo is tiny and grows as the fourth power of frequency (Rayleigh scattering, which is also why the sky is blue); around one wavelength round it rings, up to about 3.65 times its shadow area; much bigger, it settles at πr², its shadow. A metal sphere looks the same from every side, so it is used to calibrate radars.
A corner made of three flat plates at right angles sends a wave straight back to where it came from over a wide cone. That is why buoys and small craft carry corner reflectors: a 30 cm corner gives about 33 m² at 9.41 GHz, more than a cabin cruiser, from a thing you can hold. The international rules for ships (SOLAS chapter V) ask small vessels to carry a radar reflector, if practicable, so they can be seen at both 9 and 3 GHz. The "buoy reflector" here is the common octahedral kind, eight corners in one, hung "catch rain" with one corner cupped upward.
Stealth shaping works the other way. Pyotr Ufimtsev published equations for the echoes from edges in Moscow in 1962; the designers of the American F-117 (first flown in 1981) used them. The computers of the 1970s could only work out flat panels, which is why it is faceted. Every flat panel is tilted so its mirror flash goes up to the sky or down into the ground, never back to the radar, and the edges are lined up in a few directions so their spikes come only from those few directions. Compare the upright box and the stealth shape here: the same plan, but the sides lean 40°.
Ships have the same problem. A ship's upright side and the sea make a huge corner reflector, and every upright deckhouse, mast, ventilator and locker adds a corner or a post of its own. In 1974 Merrill Skolnik fitted measurements of ships at low grazing angles with a simple rule: the median echo is σ = 52 √f D1.5 m², f in megahertz and D the displacement in kilotonnes. Built that way, a 3,500 t destroyer comes out at about 33,000 m² at 9.4 GHz. Since the 1990s warships have been shaped like the stealth aircraft: hull sides flared outward and superstructures leaning inward, so the flash from each flat wall, and from the wall-and-sea corner, goes up to the sky or down into the sea; masts are closed in with flat panels, and boats, ropes and fittings go behind doors. Shaping can't fix everything: rails and stanchions, missile canisters, gun mounts and aerials still send echoes back, so they are painted with radar-absorbent material (RAM), screened and covered as part of the crew's routine care of the ship (radar-absorbing ship's husbandry, RASH), or made of glass fibre. On this page the modern ships come out about 15 dB under Skolnik's figure for their size all metal, and about 21 dB under with RAM/RASH, so a radar sees them at about a third of the range. That fits public claims of a destroyer with the echo of a fishing boat.
A glass-fibre hull is a thin sheet of dielectric: most of the wave goes through it, so the radar sees the engine, the fuel tank and the people inside, slightly dimmed. How much the sheet reflects swings with its thickness against the wavelength inside it (a sheet half a wavelength thick reflects nothing, which is how radomes are made). That is why small GRP boats are hard to see and are asked to carry a radar reflector.
The Python script RCS.py this app grew from loads an aircraft model and multiplies each triangle's area by a constant "10 dBsm". That makes a histogram of triangle sizes rather than an echo: σ isn't a property of a material per square metre. It depends on the wavelength, on the angle each part is seen from, and on how the parts' echoes add up. This page does that sum.
HOW IT WORKS
- Sphere: the exact Mie series for a perfectly conducting sphere.
- Flat plate: physical optics, σ = 4πA²/λ² · cos²θ · [sin(ka sin θ)/(ka sin θ)]², k = 2π/λ. Its first null is where sin θ = λ/(2a).
- Cylinder (lying on the turntable, as long as four diameters): side by the physical-optics formula near broadside, σ = 2πrL²/λ · cos θ · [sin(kL sin θ)/(kL sin θ)]²; the flat ends as discs, 4π(πr²)²/λ² · [2J₁(x)/x]².
- Dihedral: two square plates at 90°, fold upright. The double bounce by geometric optics, σ = 16π(ab/λ)² sin²(45° − |θ|), up to 8π(ab/λ)² looking into the fold.
- Trihedral: three triangular plates, triple bounce by the effective-area method (the returning beam is the overlap of the corner's outline and its mirror image through the corner): 4πL⁴/3λ² on its axis. The double bounces between pairs of its triangular faces are left out.
- Buoy reflector: eight square corners (triple bounce as above) and twelve dihedrals (double bounce, with physical optics for the spread along the fold).
- Upright box, stealth shape, vessels: flat metal facets by physical optics. Each facet's integral is done exactly, round its edges. By default the facets' powers are added (a smooth envelope); IN STEP adds their waves with phase, which gives the rapid flicker real echoes have.
- Ships: hull, deckhouses, gun houses and enclosed masts as flat facets; masts, funnels, gun barrels and parked aircraft as cylinders (physical optics near broadside, any lean); on the 1960s destroyer and the carrier, small fittings (not drawn) as upright corners and posts of fixed random sizes and directions, sized so the old ship's median sits near Skolnik's formula. The modern ships' fittings are placed and drawn instead: guardrails and stanchions along the deck edge, four-tube missile canisters pointing 55° off the bow to fire across the deck, close-in weapon drums, the gun barrel. Small parts behind the hull or a deckhouse are hidden from the radar. RAM/RASH: one generic magnetic paint 1.8 mm thick (about −10 dB from 3 to 10 GHz, almost nothing at VHF, where it is a tiny fraction of a wavelength) on the masts and as the screens round the canisters; glass-fibre rails and stanchions with a 6 mm wall. Ship plating is dished between frames: modelled as 8 mm rms height and 0.05 rms slope, it keeps e−(4πh cos θ/λ)² of each mirror flash (about 35% at 3 GHz, almost none at 9.4 GHz) and spreads the rest by geometric optics into a lobe a few degrees wide. Away from the mirror angle (beyond three times the slope) a flat plate's echo comes from its straight edges, which dishing leaves alone, so that part is kept: each leaning face still leaves a narrow spike in the direction it faces.
- On the sea (calm, reflection coefficient ρ = 0.9 at grazing): each echo also comes back off the sea both ways (ρ⁴), and every upright wall, post and corner forms a corner with the sea whose two paths (wall then sea, sea then wall) are equal in length and add in step (4ρ²). A wall leaning α from upright sends that corner beam 2α off, so it is multiplied by sinc²(k·2h·sin α) for a wall h high: a few degrees of flare is enough to lose it. The paths are added as powers; the lobing between direct and sea paths depends on the radar's height and range and is left out (Radar Principles shows it).
- Glass fibre (εr 4.2, loss tangent 0.015): the power a sheet reflects and lets through, straight on, by the Fresnel formulas with the reflections inside the sheet summed, averaged over ±2 mm round 8 mm (hull) and 5 mm (wheelhouse). The engine is a rough metal block seen through the hull twice; its sterndrive leg, raked 12°, is outside.
The simplifications: the targets are perfectly conducting metal (except the glass-fibre boat), in free space unless they are vessels on the sea, seen level at 0° elevation. Physical optics has no proper edge diffraction or creeping waves, nothing shadows anything else except the small fittings on a ship, hidden behind its hull and deckhouses, and only the corner terms above bounce more than once. Physical optics gives the same answer for either polarisation. When the target is under about a wavelength across, the optics formulas stop holding (the page says so); only the sphere is exact at every size. The typical values in COMPARE are rounded figures of the kind radar textbooks list; real ones swing ten times or more as a target turns. The ship figure is Skolnik's 1974 formula for the median echo of a ship at low grazing angles, σ = 52 √f D1.5 (f in MHz, D in kilotonnes).
FURTHER WATCHING AND READING