×
About Printer Dots
Many colour laser printers and copiers add a hidden code to every page they print: a grid of tiny yellow dots, repeated across the whole sheet, that gives the machine's serial number and the date and time of printing. The dots are pale yellow on white, so you won't usually notice them; a magnifier or a blue light shows them. This page is an examiner's bench for finding and reading them.
UNDER BLUE LIGHT : a printed page, with its dots drawn where a printer of this kind puts them. Move the loupe over it. Under white light the yellow dots are hard to see; switch to BLUE and they turn dark, because yellow ink soaks up blue light while white paper reflects it. FIELD sets how much of the page the loupe shows. READ THIS GRID takes the dots under the loupe to DECODE.
DECODE : the 15 by 8 grid, as you would copy it down from the loupe. Click a place to add or remove a dot. Each column read from top to bottom is a number (the dots in the rows marked 64, 32, 16, 8, 4, 2 and 1 add up); the columns say the minute, hour, day, month, year and serial number. The top row and the left column are parity: every column and every data row (all rows but the top) must hold an odd number of dots. The top row isn't checked; with 15 odd columns and 7 odd data rows it always ends up even. Copy one dot in a data row wrong and its row and column fail and cross at the slip; a slip in the top row makes only its column fail. FIX AS ONE SLIP flips the marked dot, which is right only if exactly one dot was misread: three slips on the corners of a rectangle fail in exactly the same way, and the "fix" then gives a different grid that passes. Two slips in different rows and columns are seen but can't be placed; four on the corners of a rectangle slip through unseen. Passing parity never proves a reading is right.
ENCODE : type a made-up serial number, a date and a time, and see the grid a printer of this kind would print. PRINT ON THE DESK PAGE puts it on the page under the lamp.
THE WINNER CASE : the best-known time these dots were read from a published document, and what is and isn't known about it.
HIDING : what happens to the dots when a page is copied in colour, in grey or in black and white, and how the DEDA tool from TU Dresden adds dots of its own so the code no longer reads.
THE STORY
Colour copiers became good enough in the 1980s and 1990s that people worried about them being used to copy banknotes. Some makers added hidden marks that trace a page to the machine that printed it. In 2004, a Xerox research fellow, Peter Crean, told PC World that Xerox's colour laser printers put the machine's serial number on every page, as a way for law enforcement to trace counterfeiters. Printer makers have never published how the codes work.
In 2005 the Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF) published a detailed decoding of the dot pattern of the Xerox DocuColor range, worked out from sample printouts, some sent in by the public: the work of Robert Lee, Seth Schoen, Patrick Murphy, Joel Alwen and Andrew "bunnie" Huang. It came with a guide and a program that reads the grid, and left one column's meaning unknown. Later research, including the DEDA tool below, documented more patterns. The DocuColor layout is the one this page uses throughout. EFF also kept a list of printers that did and didn't show dots, and later warned that a printer without visible yellow dots may well mark its pages some other way.
In 2018 Timo Richter, Stephan Escher, Dagmar Schönfeld and Thorsten Strufe at TU Dresden looked at 1,286 pages from 141 printers by 18 makers. They wrote a program that finds the dot grids in a scan automatically, found a layout that hadn't been described before, and released the free tool DEDA (tracking Dots Extraction, Decoding and Anonymisation), which reads the grids and can print extra dots that spoil them. They presented the work at the ACM Information Hiding and Multimedia Security workshop in June 2018.
The dots became famous in June 2017, when a news site published a scan of a leaked National Security Agency document and readers found the dots in it within a day. The THE WINNER CASE tab tells what is known; the FBI's own court papers don't mention the dots.
HOW IT WORKS
In the DocuColor layout, a column holds 7 bits, so a number from 0 to 127. Reading EFF's column numbers from the left: 1 is row parity; 2 the minute; 3 and 4 unused; 5 the hour; 6 the day; 7 the month; 8 the year without its century (so 2017 is 17: the dots carry no century, and reading 70 to 99 as the 1900s and the rest as the 2000s is a decoder's convention, which this page follows); 9 unused; 10 a separator that is all dots; 11 to 14 the serial number, two decimal digits to a column, read from column 14 back to 11; 15 is a number that stays the same for each printer and whose meaning EFF didn't know. EFF's program shows the serial both as 8 digits and as the 6 digits in columns 13 to 11, as some printers seemed to use only six. The DEDA tool's source code reads column 4 as a maker code (0 or 4 for Xerox, 3 for Epson, 20 for Dell); EFF had found it unused in its samples, so this page leaves it empty. The hour may be in the printer's own time zone or simply set wrong: the dots say what the printer's clock said.
The dots are 0.04 inch (about 1 mm) apart, the spacing in DEDA's code for this layout. A copy of the grid takes 16 places across (15 columns and a gap) and 8 down; the band of copies below is shifted along by 16 places, so the copies sit in a staggered, chequerboard-like pattern, and a whole page carries hundreds of copies. If one copy is smudged or hidden by a picture, another can be read. How far the pattern sits from the page edge varies from page to page.
Blue light shows the dots because of how inks work: yellow ink absorbs blue light and reflects red and green. Under white light a yellow dot on white paper differs only a little from the paper. Under blue light alone, the paper reflects the blue and looks blue, while the dot reflects almost nothing and looks dark.
The scan views on HIDING turn colour into grey with the usual weights (30% red, 59% green, 11% blue), so yellow comes out as a very light grey: still there, and easy to bring out by raising the contrast. A black-and-white scan sets every point to black or white at a threshold of half way, and the light-grey dots become white. Real scanners and copiers differ; a page printed by a black-and-white printer has no yellow dots to begin with. EFF has warned that printers can also mark pages in ways that are much harder to see, so no dots under the loupe doesn't prove a page carries no code.
SIMPLIFICATIONS
The memo on the page and every serial number are made up, except EFF's published example and the one in the Winner case. The dots are drawn larger than real ones so a screen can show them. Only the Xerox DocuColor layout is shown, as EFF decoded it from the pages it had; other models and makers use other layouts (see the table on HIDING), and for several of them what every dot means isn't publicly known. The HIDING mask follows the DEDA tool's rule for this layout; the real tool works out where to print its dots from a scan of a calibration page from your own printer. The Winner grid is rebuilt from the reading published in 2017, not copied from the scan, and its unused columns are drawn empty.
FURTHER WATCHING AND READING