About Radar Navigator
A ship's radar as the officer of the watch uses it: a plotting display like an ARPA's (automatic radar plotting aid) on the bridge at night. Plot the other ships to find their course, speed and closest point of approach, and act on it: own ship turns and slows as a real ship does, the traffic follows the collision rules (the COLREGs), and the exercises go from a single crossing ship to a traffic separation scheme and a coast as the radar sees it, with a debrief at the end. How the radar itself works (pulses, power, the radar horizon, clutter) is in Radar Principles, whose sums this app shares.
TRY: nine short exercises in open sea, own ship with one to four other ships. RUN starts the clock (each turn of the aerial is 30 seconds, a minute or 3 minutes of the exercise, for an hour); click a ship's echo on different sweeps, or press PLOT ALL (from the keyboard: Tab to the scope, ◄ ► pick an echo, the lighthouse and buoys included, and Enter plots it), and from the plots the display works out her course, speed, closest point of approach and when. Order own ship's course on the dial (drag it round, or the arrow keys on it: 1°, 10° with Shift) or with PORT and STBD (5° a press, 1° with Shift; hold to keep turning), and her speed on the slider, at any time: the windows show what is ordered (ORD) beside what she is doing (HDG, and LOG for speed through the water). TIDE: the way the tide sets (its dial) and its rate; STAB: SEA or GROUND stabilisation. MOTION: RM, own ship fixed in the middle, or TM, own ship moving across the screen from an offset start until she is two-thirds of the way out, when the picture resets. DISPLAY: N UP, H UP (own ship's head at the top; the bearing scale turns with the picture, so bearings still read true) or C UP (her course at the top, reset once she steadies on a new one); TRAILS where each echo has been, for 3, 6 or 12 minutes, relative or true; VECTORS for every plotted ship, 3 to 30 minutes long, relative or true. EBL and VRM: an electronic bearing line and a variable range marker from own ship; drag either on the scope, or use the keys beside it (1° or 0.1° with Shift; the VRM steps with the range scale, 0.01 nm with Shift). The bearing reads true, to 0.1°, the range to 0.01 nm. TSS: three passage exercises in a traffic separation scheme, and COAST three more off the coast beside it (more on them below); CHART lays the scheme and the chart's coastline over the picture, and DEBRIEF, once an exercise is over, switches the table between the debrief and the contacts. In the COAST row, PI is a parallel index line (◄ ► turn it, 1° a press or 0.1° with Shift; − + move it to port or starboard; or drag it on the scope), and DANGER is how far the nearest danger on the chart is. RANGE − and RANGE + (or the − and + keys) pick the range scale, 6, 12 or 24 nm, and COPY LINK copies a link to the exercise and your settings.
THE STORY
Radar went to sea in the Second World War, and merchant ships took it up quickly after it. It did not put an end to collisions. On 25 July 1956 the liners Andrea Doria and Stockholm collided in poor visibility off Nantucket, each having seen the other on radar and misjudged where she was going; collisions like it came to be called radar-assisted. Plotting, working out another ship's course, speed and closest approach from a series of ranges and bearings, became a core skill of the watchkeeper, done by hand on a plotting sheet or on a reflection plotter over the screen. Automatic radar plotting aids, in which a computer tracks each echo and shows its vector, CPA and TCPA, came in during the 1970s, and from the mid-1980s the international safety convention (SOLAS) required them on larger ships. The collision regulations in force today were agreed in 1972 and came into force in 1977; their Rule 10 covers traffic separation schemes, the first of which, in the Strait of Dover, began in 1967 as a voluntary one.
HOW IT WORKS
Plotting. On a relative motion screen own ship stays put and every other ship moves across it at her speed relative to you. Plot a ship two or more times and the straight line through the plots (a least-squares fit) is her relative motion line; carried on, the point where it passes nearest own ship is the closest point of approach (CPA), and the time until then the TCPA. The quick test behind it all: if a ship's compass bearing stays steady while the range closes, you are on a collision course. The collision regulations say risk of collision shall be deemed to exist when the bearing of an approaching vessel doesn't change appreciably, and may exist even when it does, especially with a very large vessel or at close range (Rule 7). Plots carry small bearing and range errors (0.25° and 22 m, one standard deviation), as real ones do: more plots over a longer time give steadier answers. ANSWERS shows the true values and what each ship is doing under the rules (R15 is Rule 15). The exercises are made up, not real ships or waters.
When own ship alters. A relative motion line holds only while both ships hold their course and speed, so the page works as a plotter or an ARPA would. Each plot is kept with own ship's position at that moment, which puts the other ship's position in the true picture; the line through those gives her true course and speed, and that stays right across any alteration of your own. Her CPA and TCPA are her true motion less own ship's present motion. The relative motion line is drawn only through plots taken since own ship last steadied; older plots show dimmer (◌), and while she is turning there is no relative line at all and the table says so. Own ship turns at a rate set by her speed: a medium merchant ship of about 150 m, altering under autopilot with moderate rudder, turns on a circle of about 0.6 nm (1,100 m) radius, so 19° a minute at 12 kn and 29° at 18 kn, never more than 30°. With no way on she can't turn. Her speed follows an order with a lag: about two-thirds of a change in 3 minutes, nearly all of it in 9. A real ship slowing on her engine alone takes longer than that.
When she alters. If a ship alters course while you are plotting her, plots across her turn don't fit one straight line, and a line through them gives a confident wrong answer. So, as an ARPA does, each new plot is tested against the line through the plots before it: one more than 4 standard errors off (allowing for how far the line is carried ahead) starts a new leg, and until the new leg has 3 plots the table says MANOEUVRING and re-plot instead of a CPA. How a real tracker smooths plots and spots a turn is in Radar Tracker.
Tide and stabilisation. A tide carries everything in the water with it, own ship included; a buoy or a ship at anchor stays put. A SEA stabilised picture (gyro and log) shows motion through the water, a GROUND stabilised one (GPS) motion over the ground. Relative motion, CPA and TCPA are exactly the same in both, since the tide moves both ships alike. True vectors differ by the tide: in GROUND a ship stopped in the water seems to be under way in the direction the tide sets, a false aspect. The collision rules go by aspect, the way a ship heads through the water, so sea stabilisation is the one for collision avoidance; ground stabilisation is the one for navigation, where a buoy should stand still.
How the traffic behaves. The other ships follow the collision rules in good visibility, among themselves as well as with you, and you are not steered for: own ship does only what you order. A ship that must keep out of the way (crossing with you on her starboard side, Rule 15; overtaking, Rule 13; head on, when both alter to starboard, Rule 14; any ship meeting a fishing boat, Rule 18) acts once the CPA is under 1 nm and the other ship is within 6 nm with the CPA under 30 minutes off (or 12 minutes off at any range). She makes a substantial alteration (Rule 8): the smallest of 30° or more (20° or more for an overtaking ship), in 5° steps, that takes her 1.5 nm clear of everyone, normally to starboard, and resumes her course once she is past and clear. A stand-on ship holds her course and speed (Rule 17), but if the other has done nothing by about 2 nm (or 6 minutes) with the CPA under half a mile, she acts herself: 60° or more to starboard, not to port for a ship on her port side. Fishing boats potter about at 3 to 5 kn, changing course every 5 to 12 minutes, and don't give way. In RANDOM and BUSY STRAIT about 1 ship in 10 doesn't give way at all, as some don't at sea; in the other exercises every ship follows the rules except the one in STAND ON, which is there to show you what to do when the other ship won't. All these figures are typical of prudent practice in open water, not the rules' own words: the rules give no distances, and real watchkeepers judge by the ship, the sea room and their orders.
The traffic separation scheme. The TSS exercises are set in a made-up scheme off a made-up coast (below): two one-way lanes, each 2.5 nm wide, the NE-bound one on the south-east side so that traffic keeps to starboard, either side of a separation zone 1 nm wide, in two halves with a precautionary area between them where the routes meet. A ferry route crosses the scheme at right angles and runs in to the harbour. Buoys mark the zone's ends and the lanes' outer limits, and the one in the middle of the precautionary area has a racon, which answers the radar with the Morse letter D (dash dot dot) painted outward from just behind its echo; real racons may not answer on every turn. CHART draws the scheme over the radar picture as a modern set does: the lane limits dashed, the zone as a band, arrows for each lane's direction, the precautionary area with its caution sign, the ferry route dotted, the buoys, and the exercise's goal line in green. It is placed by own ship's position, so it sits on the buoys' echoes in either stabilisation. The scheme's widths are typical of real ones; it isn't a copy of any.
Rule 10. A ship using a scheme proceeds in the right lane in the general direction of its traffic flow, keeps clear of the separation zone, and normally joins or leaves at the end of a lane, or from the side at as small an angle to the flow as practicable. A ship should avoid crossing a lane, but if she must, she crosses on a heading as nearly as practicable at right angles to the flow, so that her aspect is plain to the lane's traffic (the rule says heading, not track, so in a tide she is set off the square). She stays out of the zone except to cross, join or leave, in an emergency, or to fish in it. A fishing vessel must not impede a ship following a lane. Rule 10 does not set aside the other rules: in a scheme, as anywhere, a crossing ship with another on her starboard side gives way (Rule 15) and an overtaking ship keeps clear (Rule 13). Being in a lane gives a ship no right of way, and a ship crossing the scheme may be the stand-on one.
The traffic in the scheme. About one ship an hour comes down each lane on average (about 14 nm apart), merchant ships at 10 to 19 kn, each on her own track 1.2 to 2.5 nm from the middle of the zone; about one in four joins or leaves at a lane's side, at 25° to it. They hold their track, not just a course, as a track-keeping autopilot does: each steers for the line between her waypoints, allows for the tide, and closes the line at up to 30°, so after giving way she comes back onto her track rather than running parallel to it. Ferries cross at 18 to 22 kn, about every 50 minutes each way, each keeping to the starboard side of the route. Fishing boats tow up and down the zone at 2 to 6 kn; one that has strayed into a lane heads back into the zone when a ship comes along it (Rule 10(i)). The ships follow Rules 13 to 18 among themselves as in open water, with three changes for the scheme: an alteration is checked for where it takes the ship over the next 5 to 15 minutes, and one that would carry a lane ship into the zone or the other lane is used only if nothing else clears; alterations go up to 60°, beyond which she slows to a half or a quarter of her speed instead, as a ship does when the scheme leaves her no room to turn; and she aims to pass 1 nm off (0.5 nm off a fishing boat working in the zone). In these exercises every ship follows the rules. Ships come into the exercise at least 18 nm off and leave once 20 nm off and opening, so you see a few at a time. Echoes show only within a typical detection range for a ship's I-band radar about 15 m up, about 1.4 times the IMO minimums: a large ship 16 nm, a fishing boat with a radar reflector 7 nm, a buoy 6.5 nm, the racon 12 nm. The table still has 4 rows: in the scheme it shows the ships you have plotted first, in the order you first plotted them (the 4 with the closest CPA if you have plotted more), then the nearest echoes you haven't; the number at its top left counts the echoes it leaves out. Every echo shows on the scope, and clicking one plots it (buoys too; PLOT ALL plots only the ships).
The passage exercises. JOIN THE LANE: join the NE-bound lane from the side and follow it to its end. CROSS THE TSS: cross both lanes at right angles, giving way as the rules say. IN THE LANE: follow the NE-bound lane with a ship to overtake, a ferry crossing and a ship overtaking you. Each has a goal line and the hour; the window beside the keys shows how far off the goal line is and where you are in the scheme, and the message line says each time you enter a lane, the zone or the precautionary area. When you reach the line or the hour is up, the debrief gives the facts: the time taken, the closest any ship came and which, how long any ship was inside your CPA limit, time in the separation zone (crossing it is allowed) and against a lane's flow, how nearly at right angles you crossed, and the angle you joined at. Its tests are this app's, since the rules give no numbers: in a lane, a heading within 60° of the lane's direction counts as going along it, more than 120° off as against it, and anything between as crossing; a crossing heading within 10° of a right angle counts as square; and joining at 30° or less counts as a small angle. Press an exercise's key again for other traffic. All the figures are typical, not any particular scheme's or ship's.
The coast. The scheme lies off a coast to its south-east, with an inshore traffic zone between the NE-bound lane and the shore. From south-west to north-east: a rocky coast with low cliffs, a low point, a bay with a sandy beach and dunes and a harbour behind two breakwaters, a high headland with cliffs about 70 m high and a lighthouse, a small bay beyond it, and cliffs again; hills of 150 to 215 m stand 3 to 4 nm inland, and there is an island off the coast beyond the headland. Shoal water, too shallow for a ship, lies off the beach either side of the harbour's approach, off the headland (with a drying rock) and round the island. It is all made up: no real place, no copied chart.
Land as the radar sees it. The land's echo is worked out along each bearing as the trace passes, over the same curved Earth as Radar Principles' HORIZON tab (a standard atmosphere), from own ship's aerial 15 m up. Marching out from own ship, the page keeps the highest elevation the beam has met so far, the sea's own curve included: ground below that line is in radar shadow and paints nothing, so the far side of a ridge or a headland is blank, and beyond the horizon only what pokes up above it shows. Ships and buoys behind land are hidden the same way, until their upperworks show above it or you open them up. Where the beam does reach, the echo depends on how steeply it meets the ground (cliffs and slopes facing you paint bright, a flat beach almost nothing: the constant-gamma rule, with γ about −12 dB), falls off with range, and near the horizon is weakened by the echo off the sea (the first lobe of the beam). So the first land you see is high ground, often well inland, and a low shore paints late: the radar's coastline lies inland of the chart's. That is why CHART draws the chart's coastline over the picture as a thin line, with the shoals dotted: the gap between the two is the point. With the EBL on, the window under the scope gives the range of the chart's coast along it and where the land first paints. Typical figures here: from about 13 nm off the beach the first land to paint is the hills, 1.5 to 2 nm inland; from 9 nm the dunes, 0.2 to 0.4 nm inland; inside about 5 nm the shore itself. Cliffs paint where the chart has them. The lighthouse on the headland is a conspicuous mark that shows to about 20 nm: click it to plot it, and its range and bearing (or the EBL and VRM on it) fix your position. Real land echoes vary a great deal with the ground, the season and the radar; these are typical values for a ship's I-band set.
Parallel indexing. A PI line is drawn on the screen parallel to the planned track, set off to one side by the distance you mean to pass a mark, such as the headland's tip. If you are on your track, the mark's echo slides along the line as you go; if it creeps inside, you are being set toward it. Fixed echoes move across a relative motion screen opposite to your track over the ground, so a PI shows the tide's set too.
No-go areas. The land and the shoals are no-go areas for the traffic. Any alteration a ship considers is checked for where it takes her over the next 12 minutes or 2 nm, and one that comes within 0.3 nm of danger is never used: she turns the other way or slows down instead. On her route she keeps at least 0.2 nm off, and in the fairway she keeps to her side of it and slows rather than turns for other ships (below). If own ship touches shoal water or land she is aground: the exercise ends there, and the debrief says where.
Port and coastal traffic. Ships leave the harbour down the fairway, cross the inshore zone and join the NE-bound lane at its end beyond the precautionary area; ships bound in leave that lane at its side at about 25°, cross the inshore zone and come up the fairway to the entrance between the breakwaters, slowing to about 8 kn in the fairway, 6 at the entrance and 4 inside. The ferry crosses the scheme on her route, then turns in to the fairway.
The fairway (Rule 9). The harbour's fairway is a dredged channel 0.5 nm wide on the leading line, about 2.5 nm long from just outside the breakwaters to its seaward end; CHART draws its limits. It counts as a narrow channel: a ship in it keeps as near to its outer limit on her starboard side as is safe and practicable (Rule 9(a)). Here each ship holds a track 0.1 nm to starboard of the leading line, so ships going in and coming out pass port to port about 0.2 nm apart, close by open-sea standards but normal in a channel. Meeting a ship coming the other way, a ship in the fairway moves over to 0.18 nm off the line, and slows down (to half speed, at least 4 kn) only if that still wouldn't leave 0.12 nm between them; she doesn't make a big alteration, since there is no room, and she is back on her usual track and speed once they have passed. A ship lined up on the fairway from seaward treats a ship coming out of it the same way, rather than as a Rule 14 or 15 encounter. A ship on passage that has turned away to give way, or slowed down, goes back to her route once that alone would pass 0.8 nm clear, after 8 minutes at most, instead of waiting for the full 1.5 nm: no ship heads away from her destination for long. The breakwater entrance itself, 0.24 nm wide, is taken in the middle. The fairway's figures are typical of a small port's approach channel, not any real one's. Coasters use the inshore zone, as ships bound to or from a port inside it may (Rule 10(d)), keeping to the starboard side of it and rounding the headland at least 0.6 nm outside its shoal.
The coast exercises. HARBOUR EXIT: leave the harbour and keep to the starboard side of the fairway out to its seaward end, then cross the inshore zone and join the NE-bound lane at its end. A ship crossing the scheme toward the harbour comes in down the leading line; she starts about 7.6 nm off, beyond the 6 nm screen, and you meet her in the fairway about 20 minutes in, passing port to port (Rule 9). Its debrief adds how long you kept to the starboard side of the fairway, and any time in its middle or on its wrong side. HEADLAND: round the headland in the inshore zone, bound for the small bay beyond it, with the PI line set 1.2 nm off and a 1 kn tide setting you inshore; a coaster at anchor in the bay is hidden behind the headland until you open it up, and then gets under way across your bow. LANDFALL: close the coast from seaward across the precautionary area on the 24 nm scale, where the high ground paints long before the low beach, and fix your position by the lighthouse; a NE-bound ship crosses from starboard. Each sets its own range scale. Their debriefs add the closest you came to danger (once out of the harbour) and any grounding, and the TSS exercises' debriefs do too. The coast's heights, its echoes and its traffic are typical figures, not any real coast's, radar's or port's.
Everything here is made up and typical: the ships, the scheme, the coast and the figures are not any real ship's, chart's or radar's, and the rules are applied as a prudent watchkeeper might in good visibility. It is a way to see the ideas work, not training for a certificate.
FURTHER WATCHING AND READING