applets.

Monty Hall

← All apps

About the Monty Hall Problem

A car is behind one door and goats are behind the others. You pick a door. The host, who knows where the car is, opens all the other doors but one, always showing goats. Do you stick with your door or switch to the one he left shut? Play it yourself, then let the computer play thousands of games each way.

THE STORY

The puzzle is named after Monty Hall, the host of the American game show Let's Make a Deal, which began in 1963. The statistician Steve Selvin set it as a puzzle in a letter to the journal The American Statistician in 1975.

It became famous in 1990, when a reader put it to Marilyn vos Savant, whose "Ask Marilyn" column in Parade magazine was read by millions. She answered: switch, because you win two times in three. Around 10,000 readers wrote in, nearly 1,000 of them with PhDs, and many told her she was wrong, some of them rudely. She was right. Even Paul Erdős, one of the greatest mathematicians of the century, is said to have refused to believe it until he was shown a computer simulation, like the one on this page.

WHY SWITCHING WINS

Your first pick is right only 1 time in 3. The host never opens the car's door, so whenever your first pick was wrong, which is 2 times in 3, the one other door he leaves shut must hide the car. Switching wins exactly when your first pick was wrong.

Try it with 100 doors: you pick one, the host opens 98 doors full of goats and leaves just one other door shut. Would you really stick?

FURTHER WATCHING AND READING

Doors

PLAY

Your games
YouGamesWinsWin %

SIMULATE

Games
StrategyGamesWinsWin %Expected