applets.

Every Map Is Wrong

← All apps

About Every Map Is Wrong

A globe can't be flattened without stretching or tearing it, so every flat map of the world gets something wrong: sizes, shapes, distances or directions. This page lets you see what each kind of map gives up.

TRUE SIZE is Mercator's map. Press on any country and drag it: the page moves the real outline over the globe (turning it along the great circle between the old and new places, so its true shape and size never change) and draws it again on Mercator's map, which swells it towards the poles and shrinks it towards the equator. The table gives each shape's true area and how many times too big the map draws it where it is now and where it started (as a share of how the map draws areas at the equator). Arrow keys move the chosen shape a degree at a time (Shift for five), Delete sends it home.

PROJECTIONS shows the same world on nine maps. Tissot's circles are real circles on the globe, all the same size (about 830 km across), projected point by point: watch what each map does to them. Tissot's own rule is about very small circles, which every map turns into ellipses; circles this big come out close to ellipses. A map that keeps small circles round everywhere (conformal) can't keep their size; a map that keeps their size (equal-area) has to squash them into ellipses almost everywhere, keeping them round only along certain lines or at certain points. Point at the map to read the scales there. The figures under "Measured on this map" are worked out from the projection, on land between 80°S and 80°N.

ROUTES compares two ways from A to B: the great circle, the shortest way over the globe, and a constant compass course (a rhumb line), which crosses every meridian at the same angle. On Mercator's map the compass course is a straight line and the great circle usually bows towards the pole. The globe is turned to face the middle of the route, and from there the great circle is the straight line and the compass course bends. Along the equator or a meridian the two routes are the same. Drag A or B, or turn the globe. FLY sends a plane each way at the same speed.

PEEL cuts the globe into gores, the strips printed for covering globes. Each gore here is drawn so that its middle meridian and every parallel keep their true lengths, so the gores keep areas exactly, and the more gores, the less they bend shapes. However many you cut, they cover only 2/π (about 64%) of the paper strip they sit in. Close the gaps and the map can lie flat in one piece, but only by stretching the parallels: at 100% it is the plate carrée.

THE STORY

Gerardus Mercator published his world map in 1569, "corrected for the use of sailors": on it, a course steered at a constant compass bearing is a straight line, so a navigator could lay a ruler from port to port and read off the bearing. To make that work every direction has to be right at every point, so he stretched the map north and south exactly as much as the parallels are stretched east and west, by the secant of the latitude: twice at 60°, nearly six times at 80°, without end at the pole. Edward Wright published the first accurate tables for drawing it in 1599. Navigators took it up fully only in the 18th century, and sea charts still use it.

In a paper written in 1775 Leonhard Euler proved that no map of a sphere can keep every distance true to scale. Carl Friedrich Gauss went further in 1827 with his Theorema Egregium ("remarkable theorem"): the curvature of a surface can be measured from inside it, without leaving it, and bending without stretching can't change it. A sheet of paper has none of this curvature (rolling it into a cylinder or a cone adds none, which is why those unroll flat), but a sphere is curved in every direction, so no flattening of it can keep all lengths. Nicolas Auguste Tissot showed in 1859 how to picture what a map does to each small patch: a tiny circle on the globe becomes an ellipse on the map.

James Gall described his equal-area map to the British Association in Glasgow in 1855; Arno Peters launched the same projection in 1973 as a fairer picture of the world, and the argument over it ran for decades. Karl Mollweide's equal-area ellipse dates from 1805. Arthur Robinson designed his map in 1963 for Rand McNally, aiming for a pleasing look rather than any exact property; National Geographic used it from 1988 and moved in 1998 to Oswald Winkel's tripel of 1921, which balances size, shape and distance errors. Bojan Šavrič, Tom Patterson and Bernhard Jenny published the Equal Earth map in 2018: equal-area, with a shape like Robinson's. The azimuthal equidistant map keeps true distances and directions from its centre; the polar one is the map in the United Nations emblem. Martin Waldseemüller's printed globe gores, which are thought to date from 1507, show how old the peeling idea is.

Web maps (Google's among them) use a form of Mercator because it keeps small shapes true at any zoom; in 2018 Google Maps on desktop began showing a globe when zoomed far out.

HOW IT WORKS

Country outlines are Natural Earth's 1:110 million Admin 0 countries (public domain; made with Natural Earth, naturalearthdata.com), rounded to 0.02°. Areas are worked out on a sphere with the Earth's surface area (radius 6,371 km); at this level of detail they come within a few per cent of official figures (Greenland comes out at 2.19 million km² against 2.17 million; Africa, from the African countries in this outline set, at 30.0 million against about 30.4 million with all its islands). Small islands are missing. The page doesn't name disputed areas.

Every projection is the textbook formula on a sphere (real maps use the slightly flattened Earth; it makes no visible difference at this size). Robinson's map is defined by a table every 5°; Robinson gave no rule between the rows, so the page uses a smooth cubic curve through them. Mercator is cut off at 82° north and south, since the pole would be infinitely far away. The red circles are true circles on the globe, projected point by point. The scales in the readouts and the measured figures come from the derivatives of each projection, taken numerically. On PEEL the worst-case figures are measured between 80°S and 80°N: with the gaps closed, the stretch grows without limit towards the poles. Great circles are drawn by interpolating along the sphere; distances are on the same sphere, so they can differ from airline figures by up to about half a per cent.

Real flights rarely fly the exact great circle: they ride or dodge the jet stream and keep out of closed airspace. Since 2022 British and most other European airlines can't cross Russia, so their London to Tokyo flights go a long way round: some over Greenland, Canada and Alaska, others south over Turkey and Central Asia.

FURTHER WATCHING AND READING