applets.

Keeping the Lights On

← All apps

About Keeping the Lights On

Every big synchronous generator on the grid of Great Britain (nuclear, gas, biomass, hydro and pumped storage) turns in step with every other; most wind farms, solar panels, batteries and the interconnectors connect through power electronics instead, and don't. A synchronous machine with one pair of poles spins at exactly 3,000 revolutions a minute when the grid runs at 50 Hz. The whole country shares that one frequency, and it moves the moment the power going in and the power being used stop matching. Too little supply and every machine slows a little, giving up some of its spinning energy; too much and they all speed up. Keeping the frequency near 50 Hz, second by second, is the job of the national control room, run since 1 October 2024 by the National Energy System Operator (NESO), which took over from National Grid ESO. This page is a teaching model, not the real grid: the plant is lumped together, the numbers are typical rather than real, and it is no guide to how the real control room is run.

CONTROL ROOM: pick a job and press START. The STEPS card walks you through it one step at a time: each step ticks itself off when it's done, the controls it needs glow, and the numbered buttons let you read any step again. Point at anything and the line under the card says what it is, or why it's greyed out. Time runs at the speed you pick (×1 is real time; ×1200 is 20 minutes a second); PAUSE stops it and RESUME carries on, and the desk works while paused. The wall shows the map, the stations and the frequency meter; the pen recorders draw the whole run. On the desk: GAS (blocks of 800 MW that take 20 minutes to start, then follow your set point slowly), PUMPED STORAGE (fast once it's spinning), BATTERIES (held for automatic frequency response, or used by hand), INTERCONNECTORS (imports and exports, changed slowly), and the desk phone, to ask big users to turn down, or to call reserve. AT THE DESK: THE TEXTBOOK hands the desk to an automatic operator that plans ahead from the forecast; when you run a job yourself it runs the same one alongside you, and the debrief compares the two. TAKE OVER swaps back mid-run. The five jobs run as a course: each debrief offers the next.

WHY 50 Hz: one sudden loss of power, worked out: how fast the frequency falls depends on how much is spinning (the inertia), and where it stops depends on how much automatic response is held and how fast it arrives. THE DAY: the textbook runs a whole day, and the chart shows where the power came from, hour by hour, and how much was spinning.

THE STORY

The legal limits for the frequency in Britain are 49.5 to 50.5 Hz, 1% either side of 50; the system operator normally keeps it within 0.2 Hz. The grid of Great Britain runs on its own: its links to Ireland, France, Belgium, the Netherlands, Norway and Denmark are direct-current cables, so they carry power but not the frequency.

Demand changes all the time, and some changes come all at once. When a big programme on television stops, millions of people put the kettle on in the same few minutes: a "TV pickup". The largest recorded was about 2,800 MW, at the end of the penalty shoot-out in the 1990 World Cup semi-final between England and West Germany. Fast plant meets pickups like these, above all pumped storage. Dinorwig, inside a mountain in north Wales, has six machines and 1,728 MW; its operator says that with the machines already spinning in air it can go from nothing to 1,320 MW in 12 seconds.

On Friday 9 August 2019 at 16:52:33, lightning struck the 400 kV line between Eaton Socon and Wymondley, north of London. The protection cleared the fault in under a tenth of a second, as it should; about 150 MW of small generators on the local networks disconnected, as expected. But at the same moment the Hornsea offshore wind farm dropped from 799 MW to 62 MW, and the steam turbine at Little Barford power station tripped, losing 244 MW. Neither should have happened. The fall in frequency was so fast that about 350 MW more of small generators disconnected on rate-of-change protection: 1,481 MW in all, against 1,000 MW of automatic response held, which was what the security standard asked for. The response stopped the fall at 49.1 Hz and was lifting it back when, at 16:53:31, one of Little Barford's gas turbines tripped (210 MW). At 16:53:49 the frequency reached 48.8 Hz and the Low Frequency Demand Disconnection scheme cut off 931 MW of demand, 1,152,878 customers, as it is designed to; the second gas turbine went at 16:53:58 (187 MW). The frequency was back at 50 Hz by 16:57:15 and every supply was restored by 17:37. About 60 trains of one class stopped themselves when the frequency went below 49 Hz, and half of them needed a technician to restart them. Ofgem's investigation ended with Hornsea One Ltd and RWE, which runs Little Barford, each paying £4.5 million into its redress fund, and UK Power Networks £1.5 million for reconnecting customers before the system operator asked it to.

Afterwards a change to the protection settings on small generators that was already under way was pushed through (rate of change from 0.125 Hz a second to 1 Hz a second, under the Accelerated Loss of Mains Change Programme, with a deadline of 1 September 2022), and the system operator now publishes a yearly Frequency Risk and Control Report saying which risks it secures against. With more wind, solar and imports and fewer big spinning machines, inertia has fallen. The 9 August report gives 210 GVA·s that afternoon; the 2023 report lowered the system operator's minimum from 140 to 120 GVA·s, and in May 2026 Ofgem approved lowering it in stages towards 102 GVA·s, leaning on fast battery response such as Dynamic Containment to make up for it.

HOW IT WORKS

The frequency follows the swing equation: the rate of change of frequency is the power balance ΔP (supply minus demand, negative when supply is short) times 50 Hz, divided by twice the energy stored in everything spinning, df/dt = ΔP·f₀ / (2E). With E = 210 GVA·s (210,000 MW·s) and 1,481 MW lost, that's 0.18 Hz a second at first. Demand itself helps a little: motors slow down and take less power, here an assumed 2.5% of demand for each hertz. The model steps every 0.05 s.

Inertia is added up from what is running: per MW of nuclear 6.5 MW·s, per gas block 6,500 MW·s, per MW of other spinning plant 6 MW·s, per MW of demand 2 MW·s (motors), and 1,150 MW·s for each of the six pumped-storage machines while they spin. These are the page's own round figures, chosen so that the mix on 9 August comes out near the report's 210 GVA·s. Wind, solar, batteries and interconnectors add none.

Automatic response: gas plant governors give 20 MW a block, all of it by 0.5 Hz off, following with a 6 s time constant (about two-thirds in 6 s, nearly all within 15 s); other plant and slower services as set for each job; batteries held for response follow the Dynamic Containment shape (very little inside 0.2 Hz, all of it by 0.5 Hz, within a second). Demand disconnection cuts 5% of demand at 48.8 Hz (931 MW in the replay), counted as about 1,240 customers a MW, the 9 August ratio; reconnecting is in four blocks. Below 47.5 Hz the model stops.

The 9 August replay takes the losses, their times, the 29 GW of demand, the 210 GVA·s and the response held from the system operator's report to Ofgem. How fast that response arrives isn't in the report, so the page picked speeds that make the replay follow the recorded trace: about 49.1 Hz at 16:52:58 and 48.8 Hz at 16:53:49, as it did. The extra 200 MW lost at 49 Hz is the report's estimate of protection operating at that frequency.

What it leaves out: the grid is one point (no lines, no voltage, no constraints, no Scotland-to-England limits), there are no prices or bids, the weather forecast is right apart from gusts, and the demand shapes are typical, not any real day's. Outside the 9 August replay, gas, pumped-storage and interconnector instructions take effect at once; real ones go by phone and electronic message, and the plant has to answer. In the replay they arrive about a minute after you give them (the page's own figure), and the textbook only starts acting at 16:54:20, when the real control room did, yet it still brings the frequency back sooner than the real control room did. The phone (demand turn-down or reserve) has its own delay in every job; RECONNECT acts at once. A gas block here starts in 20 minutes, quicker than most real gas plant; pumped storage takes 90 s from still (the page's estimate). The British pumped-storage fleet is about 2.8 GW in all, and that is the size used, with 1.5 GW of batteries and 6 GW of interconnectors.

FURTHER WATCHING AND READING

A teaching model, not the real grid

With 210 GVA·s spinning, losing 1,481 MW in a second sends the whole country's frequency down about 0.18 Hz a second. On 9 August 2019 it reached 48.8 Hz, and about 1.1 million customers were cut off automatically so that the rest of the grid stayed up. The last job on this desk replays it.9 August 2019: the frequency fell to 48.8 Hz and about 1.1 million customers were cut off automatically, to save the rest of the grid. Job 5 replays it.

At the desk
Speed
00:00:00
STEPS

Frequency
Recorder 2
Gas0 MWBlocks 0
Set 0
Pumped storage0 MW
still Store 0%
Batteries0 MW
Charge 0%
Interconnectors0 MW
Set 0 · import +, export −
Giving 0 MW
Cut 0