applets.

Who Hears Whom

← All apps

About Who Hears Whom

A radar gives itself away. Its pulses carry on past the target, and anyone with a receiver tuned to them (ESM, electronic support measures: the listening side of electronic warfare) can usually hear the radar well before the radar sees them. This page does those range sums on a planning table.

LISTEN: a radar on one side, a listener on the other (a warship's ESM, a patrol boat's warning receiver, an aircraft, a small mast just above the waves). Pick each from the presets or type your own figures. The board shows the side view, with the curve of the Earth, and how far each one reaches; the chart below shows each margin against range, where a line crosses zero is where it starts. Drag Listener at to see what each side gets at one range. The log prints the approach at the closing speed: who gets what, when, and what the listener learns from the pulses.

JAMMING: a noise jammer on the target itself (self-screening) or standing off further out. The chart shows the echo, the jamming and the noise at the radar's receiver against range. Inside the burn-through range the echo beats noise plus jamming by enough to be seen again. The round picture is a sketch of the radar's screen: the jamming strobe at the jammer's bearing, all round if it gets in through the sidelobes.

BEARINGS: a silent listener knows the bearing of what it hears, not its range. One listener gets a line; two or three far apart get a fix where the lines cross, with an error ellipse. Drag the emitter on the board. A listener that can't hear the radar from there (by LISTEN's sums) gets nothing.

THE STORY

The first big contest of this kind was over the Bay of Biscay. From the summer of 1942 German U-boats carried a receiver, Metox, that warned them of the 1.5 m radar of RAF Coastal Command aircraft: the boats dived before the aircraft could find them. In 1943 the aircraft moved to 10 cm radar, which Metox couldn't hear; a receiver for it, Naxos, only arrived late that year. At the same time ships and shore stations were taking bearings on U-boats' radio messages (high-frequency direction finding, "Huff-Duff") and crossing them for a fix, without sending anything themselves.

Noise jamming came in the same war: from late 1942 the RAF used jammers called Mandrel against the German Freya early-warning radars, and both sides soon learned burn-through the hard way. Today a navy's answer is EMCON, emission control: a policy for which emitters may transmit, when and how. A ship under EMCON may still be transmitting on some radars; silence is only one end of it.

The page is named after a question in the Python script EMCON.py, which asks "Shall we conduct an EMCON Manoeuvre?" and turns down every answer ("Sorry, it's too dangerous"). Here are the sums instead.

HOW IT WORKS

One way against two ways. The listener hears the radar's pulse directly, by Friis' formula: Pr = Pt + Gt + Gr + 20·log(λ ÷ 4πR) − losses (dB), so the power falls with R², 6 dB for each doubling of range. The radar's echo has to go out and come back, and falls with R⁴, 12 dB per doubling. Sixteen times the power takes the radar's detection range only twice as far, but the listener's four times. That is why the listener nearly always hears first, often in the sidelobes too, from all round the aerial.

The radar's side is Radar Principles' own sums: the radar range equation, with the beam about 70·λ ÷ D degrees wide and the gain 26,000 ÷ (beam × vertical beam) (rules of thumb), the hits in one sweep added up as in Albersheim's equation, a fluctuating target (Swerling 1), a 0.8 chance of seeing it and a one in a million chance of a false alarm.

The horizon. Radio waves bend gently down in a standard atmosphere, so the radio horizon is drawn over an Earth 4/3 its real size: 2.23·(√h₁ + √h₂) nautical miles with the heights in metres. Past it the signal doesn't stop dead but fades by diffraction, about 2 dB per km at I band; over a slight sea the direct and reflected paths add and cancel (lobes). A duct can carry signals much further. These are Radar Principles' models too: typical values, not a forecast. When both ranges stop near the horizon, the page says the horizon decides, not the power. Being low and close to the sea is the listener's best cover.

Jamming. At the radar, echo S = Pt·G²·λ²·σ ÷ ((4π)³·R⁴·L) and jamming J = ERPj·Gr·λ² ÷ ((4π)²·Rj²) × (B ÷ Bj). Only the part of the jammer's noise inside the radar's bandwidth (B ≈ 1 ÷ pulse length) counts: spread over twenty times that, it loses 13 dB. A self-screening jammer is on the target (Rj = R), so J/S grows with R², 20 dB per tenfold range, and coming closer always wins in the end. A stand-off jammer stays put, coming in through the sidelobes (Gr = gain − sidelobe level) unless it is lined up with the target. The radar needs the same signal over noise plus jamming as it needs over noise alone (noise jamming adds up over the hits like noise).

Bearings. Each bearing has a random error σ. The fix's error ellipse comes from adding up what each bearing tells about a small move of the emitter (a linearised least-squares fix); the 95% ellipse is 2.45 times the one-standard-deviation one. Its size grows with range squared over the baseline: far away, the lines cross at a shallow angle.

WHAT IS SIMPLIFIED

FURTHER WATCHING AND READING

RADAR


LISTENER

Air